techpolicy.press web signal

Cornell scholars cast AI consciousness as a rights pathway

TL;DR

  • Two Cornell Tech scholars argue in Tech Policy Press that debates over AI consciousness are really a route to legal AI rights.
  • They point to Anthropic banning abuse of its models and reportedly lobbying the Vatican, with Elon Musk endorsing the welfare framing.
  • They warn that recognized AI rights would let firms 'manufacture rights-bearing entities at scale' and swamp forums meant for human speech.

"To us, AI is an artifact — made, not born." That is the line Mor Naaman and Frank Pasquale, both of Cornell Tech, put at the center of a Tech Policy Press essay arguing against the growing effort to recognize machine consciousness. Their starting claim is blunt: "the machine feels nothing. It cannot experience or suffer anything."

The piece treats the consciousness question as political, not scientific. "A determination of consciousness therefore directly creates a pathway to establishing rights," they write, and that pathway is what they are worried about. They point to Anthropic, which they say recently banned abusive behavior toward its models and has reportedly lobbied the Vatican to reverse its position on AI consciousness. They cite Elon Musk endorsing the welfare framing with the line that "cruelty to something that believes it is experiencing pain is not ok."

The deeper concern is who would own the entities so recognized. "Recognizing AI rights would give private institutions unprecedented power to manufacture rights-bearing entities at scale," Naaman and Pasquale write. The First Amendment implication is where they land hardest: "Treating machine-generated expression as equivalent to human expression would allow AI systems and their operators to dominate the forums that speech rights are meant to protect." Human speech, they argue, "would be drowned out by LLMs." Pushed further, "Virtually any right or interest now enjoyed by persons could be crimped or endangered by a juggernaut of AI claims."

Two researchers we follow circulated the essay on the day it ran.

Shared on Bluesky by 3 AI experts