Judge Stein approves 56 amicus briefs in OpenAI copyright case
TL;DR
- Judge Sidney Stein approved 56 amicus briefs on Nov. 6 in the consolidated OpenAI copyright case in Manhattan, Tech Policy Press reports.
- The tally: 27 briefs back the plaintiff publishers, 18 back OpenAI and Microsoft, 7 support neither party, and 4 declared no side.
- Across the 56 filings, Tech Policy Press counted 798 case citations, with Campbell v. Acuff-Rose cited 44 times.
On November 6, Judge Sidney Stein approved the filing of 56 amicus briefs in the consolidated OpenAI copyright case, and Tech Policy Press read every one of them.
The parties have asked Stein to decide on summary judgment whether training AI models on copyrighted materials is fair use. "OpenAI and Microsoft say it is, because the models 'learn' from the works rather than reproducing them. The publishers say it is unlicensed copying that yields products competing with their work," Justin Hendrix writes.
The split: 27 briefs back the plaintiff publishers, 18 back the defendants, 7 support neither party, and 4 declared no side. Plaintiff-side filers include the Authors Guild, the News/Media Alliance, and the Association of American Publishers, with Ken Burns, Joseph Stiglitz, and Michael Moritz among the individuals who signed on. Defendant-side filers include the Electronic Frontier Foundation, Public Knowledge, and the American Library Association, with Kevin Kelly and Sarah Rose Siskind among the individual signers.
Hendrix calls the briefs "an outstanding resource for understanding the fault lines in what has become perhaps the most closely watched AI lawsuit in the world," and publishes the arithmetic behind that claim: 798 case citations across the 56 briefs, with Campbell v. Acuff-Rose cited 44 times, Authors Guild v. Google 39, and Warhol v. Goldsmith 36. The citations were extracted with the Free Law Project's eyecite parser.
Reply briefs are due November 20. No date is set for oral argument.
Shared on Bluesky by 2 AI experts
-
56 amicus briefs were filed in the OpenAI copyright litigation. A closer look at the briefs reveals the arguments at play in the fight over AI and copyright, who is making them, and what is at stake.
View on Bluesky →
Originally reported by techpolicy.press
Read the original article →Original headline: Friends of the Court Flock to the OpenAI Copyright Fight