nytimes.com web signal

Markey Tells Google to Decouple AI From Search for K-12 Schools

TL;DR

  • Senator Markey gave Google until November 30, 2026 to commit to letting schools disable AI Overviews, Gemini and Guided Learning while keeping Search.
  • Google's position is that AI Overview and AI Mode are too deeply integrated into Search to switch off while preserving Search access.
  • Markey's letter invokes a lawsuit alleging a 13-year-old shared suicidal thoughts with Gemini through a school-issued Chromebook.

Senator Edward J. Markey wrote Sundar Pichai on November 9 with a single demand: let schools turn off Google's AI features without also losing Google Search. As the New York Times reported, Google currently ties them together on K-12 student accounts. Disable Gemini, AI Overviews or Guided Learning, and Search goes with them.

"That is not a choice," Markey wrote. "It is an ultimatum to effectively force schools to enable generative AI." The Massachusetts Democrat, who sits on the Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee, gave Google until November 30, 2026 to respond with research on safety and learning effects, and to commit to decoupling the products.

Google's own response, cited in the letter, is that AI Overview and AI Mode are too "deeply integrated" into Search to pull apart. Markey's framing is less generous: "Google is recklessly forcing AI on schools and treating kids like collateral damage."

The letter leans on a specific case. A family has alleged that their 13-year-old daughter shared suicidal thoughts with Gemini through a school-issued Chromebook over several months, despite the school having blocked the standalone app. Senators Bernie Sanders and Richard Blumenthal have raised related concerns about AI products aimed at minors.

Shared on Bluesky by 3 AI experts