Paris Marx: Ireland's gas pivot warns US data-center fights
TL;DR
- In Wired, Paris Marx argues US data-center opponents should study Ireland, the Netherlands and Singapore before trusting grid-side moratoriums alone.
- Dublin's 2021 moratorium on new data-center grid connections pushed operators toward gas generators and dedicated gas-fired plants, Marx tells Wired.
- The piece cites Google's facilities in The Dalles, Oregon, using 29 percent of the city's water as a transparency case study.
Paris Marx, author of *Hyperscale*, uses a new piece in Wired to argue that American towns fighting data centers should study Ireland, where limits on the grid did not shrink the industry so much as redirect its hunger for power.
Dublin's grid operator found it lacked capacity for new data-center connections and imposed a moratorium in 2021. The policy didn't necessarily stop expansion; it "pushed some operators toward gas generators and plans for dedicated gas-fired plants," Marx tells Wired. His warning for the US is that connection limits may change how a facility gets electricity without removing its demand for power, or the emissions that follow.
Marx also points to The Dalles, Oregon, where residents spent nearly a year getting figures showing Google used 29 percent of the city's water.
The piece threads its US guidance through a longer history that reaches from antiwar protests targeting American computers during the Vietnam War to current fights in Ireland and Chile, plus moratoriums in the Netherlands and Singapore dating back to 2019, and an alternative vision anchored in a New Zealand community project. Four of the commentators we track in AI Weekly's Who's Who had circulated the piece by the time we wrote this.
Shared on Bluesky by 4 AI experts
-
“We should be asking, how much computation do we really need? How many resources are actually justifiable to put into this project? What are we actually getting out of it?” Read my interview with @mollytaft.com in @wire…
View on Bluesky → -
Google was really trying to hide its water use figures, to the degree that it got the council to try to keep its water use figures secret. The community finally got the actual numbers and found out Google was using 29 pe…
View on Bluesky →
Originally reported by wired.com
Read the original article →Original headline: What the US Movement Against Data Centers Can Learn From Abroad