Seth, Block and Tononi say AI isn't conscious, may never be
TL;DR
- Anil Seth, Ned Block and Giulio Tononi argue in a Nature comment that today's AI is not conscious and may never be along current paths.
- Their first argument treats intelligence and consciousness as separable, noting the cerebellum holds nearly four-fifths of the brain's neurons without contributing to conscious experience.
- The piece rejects computational functionalism and says current deep-learning architectures are wired in ways integrated information theory considers insufficient for consciousness.
Three of the most prominent names in consciousness science, Anil Seth of the University of Sussex, Ned Block of New York University, and Giulio Tononi of the University of Wisconsin–Madison, have co-signed a Nature comment arguing that today's AI is not conscious and, along the trajectory the field is on, may never be. Seven of the researchers we follow posted it the day it ran.
Their first move is to sever intelligence from experience. 'Consciousness is about being and feeling; intelligence is about doing, or performing functions,' the piece argues, pointing out that the cerebellum, which contains nearly four-fifths of the neurons in the human brain, performs sophisticated computation without contributing directly to conscious awareness. Fluent linguistic output, on their reading, is evidence of the second thing, not the first.
The second argument rejects computational functionalism, the view that any substrate running the right program would be conscious. The authors treat biological implementation as doing work silicon substitutes cannot be assumed to replicate, framing brains as not merely computers that happen to be made of meat.
The third reason reaches into integrated information theory, Tononi's framework, and concludes that deep-learning systems fall short 'because of the way in which they are wired.' Consciousness, in this view, requires components 'to be tightly interconnected in specific ways' that today's architectures do not satisfy.
The three co-authors come from different consciousness theories, which makes the convergence the point. The comment also stresses that attributing consciousness where none exists carries greater risk for governance and resource allocation than the opposite mistake.
Shared on Bluesky by 7 AI experts (top 5 by trust)
-
1/2 Three reasons why AI is not conscious - and perhaps never will be. New in @nature.com with Ned Block @neddo.bsky.social and Giulio Tononi www.nature.com/articles/d41...
View on Bluesky → -
Three reasons why AI is not conscious and perhaps never will be www.nature.com/articles/d41...
View on Bluesky → -
Great piece on why AI is not conscious, from people who really know what they’re talking about www.nature.com/articles/d41...
View on Bluesky →
Originally reported by nature.com
Read the original article →Original headline: Three reasons why AI is not conscious and perhaps never will be