techpolicy.press web signal

Vanderbilt report maps policy response to AI bubble crash

TL;DR

  • The report 'After the AI Crash' contrasts J.P. Morgan's $5 trillion AI investment projection through 2030 with current AI revenue in the tens of billions.
  • Author Asad Ramzanali urges structural separation of hardware and model development, citing Amazon's retail and AWS split as a precedent.
  • Missouri exempts companies investing $25 million and creating 10 jobs from state and local sales and use tax, the report notes.

J.P. Morgan expects $5 trillion in AI investment between now and 2030. Current revenue from AI systems is in the tens of billions.

That math problem anchors 'After the AI Crash,' a report by Asad Ramzanali, Director of AI and Technology Policy at the Vanderbilt Policy Accelerator, discussed on a Tech Policy Press podcast hosted by Justin Hendrix. 'J.P. Morgan anticipates that we're going to invest $5 trillion between now and 2030,' Ramzanali says. Even redirecting every dollar of enterprise technology spending toward AI, he argues, would still leave hundreds of billions a year unaccounted for.

Ramzanali's position is that lawmakers should be building the policy menu now rather than after the fall. 'Instead of waiting for the crisis and hastily developing insufficient policies, lawmakers should prepare,' he says.

The report's items are concrete. Circular equity financing, where AI companies invest in each other at scales large enough that it 'messes with prices, that messes with demand,' should be halted. Private credit funding the data center buildout, which the report says includes retirement accounts and pensions, should be made more transparent. State subsidies get a direct example: in Missouri, 'if you invest $25 million and create 10 jobs, you are exempt from all state and local sales and use tax.'

On workers, the recommendations lean traditional and expansive at once: 'do the traditional things like expand unemployment insurance, get rid of work requirements for social safety,' plus a new 'Digital Works Progress Administration' modeled on the New Deal WPA that, per Ramzanali, put 'eight million people to work.' The report also urges structural separation of hardware and model development, citing the Amazon retail and AWS split as precedent: 'Amazon.com, a retailer that's online, and AWS, the web services... two very different industries.'

The closing argument is political. 'Politics change drastically during a crisis,' Ramzanali says, and the moment opens space for 'things that we've needed to do.'

Shared on Bluesky by 2 AI experts