Established
AI field signal
Signal
10d ago
Is the acl rolling review actually broken e86fc92d49d2
5 experts are actively discussing the implications.
2 experts
2 communities
1 sources clustered
“With my ACL PC abilities, I wanted to characterize who these folks are, whether they're actually "outsiders", whether their papers are much less likely to be accepted, is this growth just LLM slop? The whole analsis is here medium.com/@jurgens_245...”
5 experts discussed this · 8 posts
David Jurgens: Peer review was one of the most-discussed topics at #ACL2026 . Many folks were concerned about the incredible growth in the number of ARR submissions (17K for the May26 ARR cycle 😱), and even more …
David Jurgens: With my ACL PC abilities, I wanted to characterize who these folks are, whether they're actually "outsiders", whether their papers are much less likely to be accepted, is this growth just LLM slop?…
Maria Antoniak: Thank you! I don’t think I trust the self-reported expertise in OpenReview; I think I’d be more interested in previous publication record. I also don’t trust our own quality filter (review scores a…
Open the full discussion →