The Who's Who of AI

What the AI community is actually reading and debating — the articles its researchers, builders, ethicists and critics are sharing, and the discussions they're having, ranked by standing inside the field.

What the directory is reading

What they're debating

8 members · 45 posts ·5d ago
M.J. Crockett · Eryk Salvaggio · Emily M. Bender · SE Gyges · Alondra Nelson · Singularity's Bounty e/cc · Maxim Raginsky · Larry Hunter · Jack Stilgoe
M.J. Crockett: Joseph Weizenbaum's 1976 book, Computer Power and Human Reason, has long been out of print - used copies sell for hundreds of dollars. It's wild that this is not more widely ava…
M.J. Crockett: Weizenbaum was an MIT computer scientist who built one of the first chatbots, ELIZA. He wrote the book out of a growing sense of horror as he saw how “extremely short exposures …
M.J. Crockett: Another version of the program, called DOCTOR, simulated psychotherapy: “A number of practicing psychiatrists seriously believed the DOCTOR computer program could grow into a ne…
M.J. Crockett: He cites a psychiatrist who writes: “The human therapist, involved in the design and operation of this system, would not be replaced, but would become a much more efficient man …
Open the thread →
7 members · 28 posts ·14d ago
Ted Underwood · Ciara Rowles · Grace · tweety fish · mackuba.eu · Brett Bobley · Emile van Krieken · Luis Villa
Ted Underwood: This divide is also why half of my friends are "What will we put in the abandoned shells of these data centers when people realize they're useless?" and the other half are "Can …
Ted Underwood: Meanwhile memory chips are increasing in price so fast that by the time Neuromancer comes out this fall you will *actually* be able to get killed in Chiba City for 3 MB of hot RAM.
Ted Underwood: The tacit premise there is that coding is a narrow, purely technical application with an obvious ceiling on demand. (Which is what half of my friends do assume.) But I'm startin…
Ted Underwood: I don't belong to an evangelical religion, so that sounds good to me. Live a code-free life; enjoy summer; plant tomatoes, they're delicious!
Open the thread →
7 members · 12 posts ·2d ago
Naomi Saphra · Isaiah Bishop · Ted Underwood · Joanna Bryson · Claas Voelcker · Mark J. Nelson · David Marx
Naomi Saphra: Are students embarrassed by AI cheating? Like, there has always been rare but unstigmatized dishonesty (memorizing a frat’s archive of finals questions) and common but stigmatiz…
Naomi Saphra: I don’t know exactly what dictates cheating stigma. Ease of observation? Is there something about effort, or the margin of work required to do it honestly? Regardless, AI cheati…
Isaiah Bishop: Absolutely not
Naomi Saphra: :(
Open the thread →
7 members · 11 posts ·3d ago
Christian Wolf · David Picard · Alexander Hoyle · Jacob Eisenstein · Thomas Dietterich · Eric Brachmann · Kabir Kumar, aiplans.org
Christian Wolf: The impact of Claude: it - has become very cheap to produce submissions (quality?) - remains very expensive to evaluate them by humans. Possible solutions are limited (I don't a…
David Picard: Limit the number of sub. You start the year with 2 tokens, if you want more tokens, then you review 2x per token.
Alexander Hoyle: Per some back-of-the-envelope math, I think this doesn't pan out. Even if we capped submissions at max one per author (which no one is suggesting), we'd still have at least ~10k…
Jacob Eisenstein: i agree about the dynamic, but the trend in submissions was in place well before claude
Open the thread →
6 members · 10 posts ·1d ago
Maria Antoniak · Marzena Karpinska · Arseny Khakhalin · Christian Wolf · Thomas Dietterich · Marco Z
Maria Antoniak: hot take: don’t even use it for polishing your reviews. as an AC and SAC, the last thing i care about is your grammar, spelling, or formatting. i get the presentation issues wit…
Marzena Karpinska: funniest part is that the one i saw looked like bullet points copy-pasted from whichever-ai-tool. there was no space precisely where the bullet points changed but the person sai…
Marzena Karpinska: hot take: don’t even use it for polishing your reviews. as an AC and SAC, the last thing i care about is your grammar, spelling, or formatting. i get the presentation issues wit…
Arseny Khakhalin: Language is fixed so easily though ("please fix only typos, prepositions, grammar, and near-misses for idiomatic expressions. Don't make any substantial changes"). Or smth like …
Open the thread →
4 members · 11 posts ·14d ago
Ethan Mollick · Eli Sennesh · Singularity's Bounty e/cc · Fran Litterio · Ted Underwood
Ethan Mollick: It is weird that there is still a substantial set of people who believe "AI is mostly hype" at this stage: Five Eyes is warning about AI, exponential revenue & token use at the …
Ethan Mollick: I know I write a post like this every month, but the degree to which the refusal to believe that maybe this is not just a fake bubble thing is getting weirder all the time. And …
Ethan Mollick: And if AI is real, than even if there is a financial bubble, it just does not matter. In a world when OpenAI and Anthropic collapse under pressure, their IP will just be picked …
Ethan Mollick: You can believe there is a financial bubble if you would like. I can't guarantee there isn't one, as I discuss in the thread. It doesn't really matter much. And if you don't tru…
Open the thread →
6 members · 6 posts ·1d ago
Ted Underwood · Maria Antoniak · David Picard · Mark Riedl · Alice Schwarze · Singularity's Bounty e/cc · Andrea Lathrop
Ted Underwood: Can anyone who was there report the answer?
Maria Antoniak: Can anyone who was there report the answer?
David Picard: Hopefully nothing so that we could all get some nice vacations
Mark Riedl: I'm learning to play guitar. I hear there is a lot of money in the arts
Open the thread →
5 members · 7 posts ·15h ago
Gautam Kamath · Naomi Saphra · Martin Trapp · Marco · Eugene Vinitsky
Gautam Kamath: That account's bio says "parody." It got me too for a second. It would be more believable if he weren't 91 years old. I hope dude is enjoying his retirement.
Naomi Saphra: Anthropic just hired Gilbert Strang???
Martin Trapp: What a strange world we live in nowadays.
Marco: it fooled me also haha
Open the thread →
5 members · 12 posts ·3d ago
Marzena Karpinska · David Mimno · David Jurgens · Alexander Hoyle · Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez
Marzena Karpinska: Only 17% of May #ARR authors are qualified for reviewing, and almost 40% of papers have no qualified people?!?!
David Mimno: is anyone there suggesting not allowing submissions with no qualified reviewers? Elitist and gate-keepy yes, but is there a better option?
Marzena Karpinska: Yes, that's precisely what was suggested.
David Jurgens: I crunched some numbers for the Jan26 cycle and many of these papers do have senior author (e.g., 62% have a prof co-author), but these folks are often from related non-ACL fiel…
Open the thread →
5 members · 19 posts ·12d ago
Ted Underwood · jake · Tim Kellogg · Max Woolf · apenwarr.ca
Ted Underwood: Lately I hear academic friends celebrate open-weight or local models for a mix of three reasons: a) transparency is good for research b) they protect higher ed's autonomy from S…
Ted Underwood: The same tasks may actually use less ⚡️ in a center, b/c better hardware & caching. “I use smaller models locally”—maybe? but they cost less, so Jevons paradox can kick in. Micr…
Ted Underwood: Jevons paradox is a problem even for "smaller." I run tens of thousands of queries on small models, because it's effectively free; I think twice before doing that on frontier mo…
Ted Underwood: The cost of paying frontier labs is absolutely an incentive to go local. But I'm skeptical that there's much incentive to be efficient—because, in reality, these things just don…
Open the thread →
4 members · 12 posts ·12d ago
Eugene Vinitsky · jake · Ted Underwood · Tim Kellogg
Eugene Vinitsky: Kinda funny that bluesky is the anti-AI regulation platform
Eugene Vinitsky: Naively not what you might expect
Eugene Vinitsky: Ability to read in general
Eugene Vinitsky: Yeah, just that the anti regulation contingent is realllllly vocal
Open the thread →
5 members · 29 posts ·14h ago
VE, cybersocial occult investigator · Dan Hon · Danya Glabau · Damien Williams · Alex Hanna
VE, cybersocial occult investigator: I wonder if it would be crazy of me to consider doing a sociology PhD
VE, cybersocial occult investigator: The problem is, I should also simultaneously be doing an information science PhD and a religious studies PhD, because the thing I’m interested in is the sociology of collective …
VE, cybersocial occult investigator: Science and technology studies for studying the occult
Dan Hon: I have always wanted to do: * linguistics * socio-linguistics * anthropology * philosophy * some combination of all of those but fuck me I wouldn't touch eng lit with a barge pole
Open the thread →