Established
AI field signal
Signal
10d ago
⚡ 2343 h early
No ai is not stochastic parrot a99e57766bed
6 experts across 2 network communities independently surfaced this.
Why this matches
Research & technical analysis reaction
1 attributable expert contribution
· Will Oremus
“I reposted this, but tacking itonto this thread as well bc I think it's useful context. Margaret was also a co-author of the Stochastic Parrots paper and recently offered some thoughts on which parts of the analogy hold up (and which have been widely misund…” evidence ↗
6 experts
2 communities
1 sources clustered
How the network is reacting
Experts are approaching this through 2 distinct lenses.
Multiple readings
Concern & critique
1 expertRisks, limits and unintended consequences.
“But LLMs are, to this day, still well enough understood as stochastic parrots. It's an accurate description of the technology. Many AI models involve more than LLMs, as fellow co-author Margaret Mitchell pointed out, but it's *still* a useful critical frame…”
Research & technical analysis
1 expertEvidence, methods and technical implications.
“I reposted this, but tacking itonto this thread as well bc I think it's useful context. Margaret was also a co-author of the Stochastic Parrots paper and recently offered some thoughts on which parts of the analogy hold up (and which have been widely misund…”
17 experts discussed this · 104 posts
Will Oremus: feels like there is a group of smart and well-intentioned people who long ago made up their minds that AI Is Bad, swore off using it, and now get all their info about AI from each other. not saying…
Will Oremus: you can eschew anthropomorphizing language like "think" and "reason" and even "intelligence" but anyone who uses these tools regularly cannot fail to see that what they do is something more than ju…
Will Oremus: or if it is parroting, it's stretching the bounds of your conventional understanding of that term so far as to render it misleading. parrots cannot solve complex problems, self-interrogate and self…
Open the full discussion →